Amato's Pizzeria (Newton)
55 Mill St, Suite 2, Newton, New Jersey, 07860
Amato's Pizzeria is a hit-or-miss spot in Newton. Fans rave about the pizza and friendly service, often calling it their go-to for a quick, tasty slice. However, critics point to inconsistent pasta dishes and occasional service hiccups, with some questioning the authenticity of the recent management changes. It's a classic local pizza joint that offers great value for many, but it clearly struggles to please everyone with its broader menu.
We analyze 74 public reviews for Amato's Pizzeria (Newton) using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Stick to the pizza and specialty sandwiches; the pasta dishes are often reported as less impressive.
✓ What Works Well
- Great pizza slices
- Friendly and welcoming staff
- Fast delivery service
✗ Areas to Improve
- Inconsistent pasta quality
- Parking can be difficult
- Mixed reviews on management
- Is the pizza authentic?
- Do they offer delivery?
- Are the pasta dishes homemade?
Best pizza in Newton.
Pasta dishes feel like frozen meals.
Staff is usually very polite.
- Category Food & Beverage
- City Newton
- State New Jersey
- Postcode 07860
- Country United States
readers daily.