Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
Food & Beverage · Pizzeria

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

791 Udall Rd, West Islip, New York, 11795

Google Maps Updated: 17 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 72/100
About

Anthony's is a polarizing spot. Fans swear by the grandma slice and the sauce, calling it the best in town. Others complain about the owner's attitude and inconsistent quality. It's a classic local joint where you either love the no-nonsense vibe or find it rude. Prices are generally seen as fair, but parking is a headache.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
14
Newest
20
Highest rating
15
Lowest rating

We analyze 69 public reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Food Taste 75/100
Value for Money 80/100
Pro Tip

Stick to the grandma slice and avoid the specialty rolls during busy hours.

Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Grandma slice is a standout
  • Affordable pricing
  • Fresh ingredients

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Owner can be abrasive
  • Inconsistent food quality
  • Difficult parking
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Do they deliver to apartments?
  • Is the owner really that rude?
  • Are there more slice options?
User Feedback

Sauce is spot on

Great bang for the buck

Service is hit or miss

Location Details
Street: 791 Udall Rd
Neighborhood: West Islip
City: West Islip
State: New York
Postcode: 11795
Country: United States
Location
791 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795
Quick Info
Advertisement
📢
Your Ad Here
Reach thousands of
readers daily.