Food & Beverage · Italian Restaurant
Cafe Amalfi Restaurant
1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, Florida, 34231
Google Maps
Updated: 18 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 82/100
About
This is a small, owner-run spot that many locals adore for its authentic Italian feel and homemade touch. The owner is often praised for his passion, though some diners have had friction with his direct style. The food is generally seen as high quality, though consistency can vary.
Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
17
Newest
20
Highest rating
20
Lowest rating
We analyze 77 public reviews for Cafe Amalfi Restaurant using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Performance Scores
Food Taste
88/100
Value for Money
75/100
Pro Tip
The owner is very hands-on; be patient and polite, and you'll likely have a great experience.
Homemade pasta
Small, intimate setting
Pros & Cons
✓ What Works Well
- Authentic homemade food
- Welcoming owner
- Great pizza crust
✗ Areas to Improve
- Inconsistent service
- Small dining area
- Some find the owner's style abrasive
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is the pizza really authentic?
- Is it good for families?
- Why is the service sometimes slow?
User Feedback
Best pizza in Sarasota
Authentic Italian gem
Owner is very passionate
Quick Info
- Category Food & Beverage
- Neighborhood Gulf Gate
- City Sarasota
- State Florida
- Postcode 34231
- Country United States
More Food & Beverage
