251 E Main St, Reedsburg, Wisconsin, 53959
Calabria Pizza & Pasta is a polarizing spot in Reedsburg. Most diners rave about the authentic, homemade Italian flavors, especially the garlic knots and pasta dishes. However, service consistency is a major pain point, with many reports of rude staff and order errors. While the food is often described as a hidden gem, the management style seems to have soured the experience for long-time patrons. It is a hit-or-miss spot where the kitchen shines but the front-of-house struggles.
We analyze 66 public reviews for Calabria Pizza & Pasta using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Stick to carryout if you want to avoid the loud dining room, but double-check your order before leaving the parking lot.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
The food is spot on, but the service needs a serious overhaul.
Best garlic knots in town, hands down.
New management has really dropped the ball on customer care.