Food & Beverage · Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Carmela's Restaurant Pizzeria

1021 NY-17K, Montgomery, New York, 12549

Google Maps Updated: 16 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 76/100
About

Carmela's is a long-standing local spot that has recently undergone a renovation. While many regulars appreciate the updated space and consistent food quality, there are mixed reviews regarding service and pricing. Some diners find it to be a great spot for a casual meal, while others have had disappointing experiences with service and food consistency. It remains a popular choice for many in the Montgomery area.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
15
Newest
20
Highest rating
20
Lowest rating

We analyze 75 public reviews for Carmela's Restaurant Pizzeria using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Food Taste 77/100
Value for Money 72/100
Pro Tip

The cauliflower pizza is a surprisingly good option if you're looking for something different.

Casual Dining
Renovated Space
Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Nice, updated atmosphere
  • Consistent food quality for many
  • Friendly staff

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Inconsistent service quality
  • Some items are overpriced
  • Occasional food quality issues
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Do they offer catering?
  • Is it good for families?
  • Are there gluten-free options?
User Feedback

Great spot for a casual dinner.

The pizza is consistently good.

Service can be hit or miss.

Location Details
Street: 1021 NY-17K
Neighborhood: Montgomery
City: Montgomery
State: New York
Postcode: 12549
Country: United States
Location
1021 NY-17K, Montgomery, NY 12549
Quick Info
Advertisement
📢
Your Ad Here
Reach thousands of
readers daily.