Compass Insurance Group LLC
Financial Services · Insurance Agency

Compass Insurance Group LLC

103 W Boggstown Rd, Shelbyville, Indiana, 46176

Google Maps Updated: 14 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 94/100
About

Compass Insurance Group, led by Gary Nolley, is highly regarded for its expertise in Medicare and supplement insurance. Clients appreciate Gary's honest, pressure-free approach and his ability to explain complex insurance rules in simple terms. Many customers mention saving significant money and feeling confident in their coverage choices. The team is described as friendly, professional, and always available to answer questions. It's a go-to agency for those navigating the complexities of Medicare, with many clients referring friends and family due to their positive experiences.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
12
Newest
20
Highest
19
Lowest

We analyze 71 Google Maps public reviews (Most relevant, Newest, Highest rating, Lowest rating) from every angle to find the real story so you know exactly what to expect. We use Artificial Intelligence to analyze these reviews and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Process Efficiency 96/100
Staff Helpfulness 98/100
Pro Tip

Ask Gary to review your current plan annually; he's known for finding better options as your needs change.

Medicare Expertise
Financial Planning
Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Expertise in Medicare and supplements
  • Honest, pressure-free guidance
  • Significant cost savings for clients

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Limited feedback on non-Medicare services
  • High demand for appointments
  • None reported in the provided reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Which Medicare Advantage plan is best for me?
  • Can you help me with my social security paperwork?
  • How do I save money on my supplements?
User Feedback

Gary is a life saver for Medicare.

They made the transition so easy.

Honest, educated, and professional.

Location Details
Street: 103 W Boggstown Rd
Neighborhood: Shelbyville
City: Shelbyville
State: Indiana
Postcode: 46176
Country: United States
Location
103 W Boggstown Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Quick Info
Advertisement
📢
Your Ad Here
Reach thousands of
readers daily.