Food & Beverage · Diner
Coney Island Diner
10 Railroad Ave, Middletown, New York, 10940
Google Maps
Updated: 18 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 70/100
About
Coney Island Diner is a local institution with a long history, and for many, it is a nostalgic spot for a classic hot dog. While the food is generally well-regarded, there are some concerns about cleanliness and service consistency. It is a no-frills, old-school diner that is great for a quick bite, but don't expect a modern or polished experience.
Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
11
Newest
20
Highest rating
19
Lowest rating
We analyze 70 public reviews for Coney Island Diner using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Performance Scores
Food Taste
65/100
Value for Money
70/100
Pro Tip
Stick to the classic coney dogs; they are the reason people keep coming back.
Old-School Diner
Classic Menu
Pros & Cons
✓ What Works Well
- Classic hot dogs
- Nostalgic vibe
- Affordable prices
✗ Areas to Improve
- Cleanliness issues
- Inconsistent service
- Hit-or-miss food quality
Frequently Asked Questions
- Are the hot dogs fresh?
- Why is the service so slow?
- Is it open late?
User Feedback
Best hot dogs in town.
Service is hit or miss.
Feels like a step back in time.
Quick Info
- Category Food & Beverage
- City Middletown
- State New York
- Postcode 10940
- Country United States
More Food & Beverage
