1176 NJ-23, Sussex, New Jersey, 07461
Elias Cole is a long-standing local favorite for classic American comfort food. Known for its homemade pies and fresh-baked bread, it offers a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere that many locals have frequented for decades. While service can occasionally be hit-or-miss, the overall sentiment is positive, with many praising the generous portions and friendly staff. Note that it is a cash-only establishment.
We analyze 66 public reviews for Elias Cole using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Always bring cash, as they do not accept credit cards.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
The lemon meringue pie is legendary.
Feels like a true taste of home.
Great comfort food at fair prices.