Hathaway Insurance Agency
Financial Services · Farmers Insurance Agency

Hathaway Insurance Agency

594 1st St, Idaho Falls, Idaho, 83401

Google Maps Updated: 14 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 72/100
About

Hathaway Insurance Agency presents a stark contrast in reviews. While Forrestt Payne and his team receive glowing praise for their professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to client needs, the agency owner and his son face severe criticism regarding leadership, communication, and business practices. Clients who work with Forrestt feel well-protected and valued, while others report frustration with the agency's management and lack of support.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
10
Newest
20
Highest
20
Lowest

We analyze 70 Google Maps public reviews (Most relevant, Newest, Highest rating, Lowest rating) from every angle to find the real story so you know exactly what to expect. We use Artificial Intelligence to analyze these reviews and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Process Efficiency 70/100
Staff Helpfulness 72/100
Pro Tip

If you choose this agency, specifically request to work with Forrestt Payne to ensure a high level of service and attention.

Mixed Management
Top-tier Agent Available
Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Forrestt Payne's exceptional service
  • Competitive rates
  • Thorough policy explanations

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Leadership and management concerns
  • Communication issues with ownership
  • Inconsistent service quality
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Can you help me with a complex policy?
  • How do I get a quote?
User Feedback

Forrestt is a top-notch agent.

Management needs to improve.

Great service if you work with the right person.

Location Details
Street: 594 1st St
Neighborhood: Downtown
City: Idaho Falls
State: Idaho
Postcode: 83401
Country: United States
Location
594 1st St, Idaho Falls, ID 83401
Quick Info
Advertisement
📢
Your Ad Here
Reach thousands of
readers daily.