368 New Hempstead Rd, Suite 1, New City, New York, 10956
This spot was a local staple for decades, but recent ownership changes have left regulars feeling let down. While some still enjoy the pizza and sandwiches, many complain about poor food quality, incorrect orders, and rude service. The consensus is that the magic is gone, and it feels more like a disorganized convenience store now. Long-time fans are actively looking for new places to eat. It is a classic case of a beloved neighborhood joint losing its touch.
We analyze 70 public reviews for Hilltop Deli & Pizza using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Stick to the classic pizza slices if you must visit, as the custom sandwich orders are where most errors occur.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
Food quality is not what it used to be.
Orders are consistently wrong.
Staff attitude needs a major fix.