241 NY-6N, Mahopac, New York, 10541
Holy Smoke is a polarizing spot that locals either love for its massive portions and tender brisket or avoid due to inconsistent quality. While many rave about the ribs and the rustic, welcoming vibe, others report cold, reheated food and lackluster service. The outdoor beer garden is a major hit, though the indoor dining area feels a bit dark to some. It is a classic hit-or-miss joint where the BBQ sauce is often the star of the show. If you catch them on a good day, it is a total bang for the buck.
We analyze 76 public reviews for Holy Smoke using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Stick to the ribs and brisket; the sides are often secondary to the main smoked meats.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
Ribs are spot on when fresh.
Sides can be hit or miss.
Service speed varies wildly.