Michael J. Sileo, MD
Health & Medical · Orthopedic Surgery

Michael J. Sileo, MD

500 Commack Rd, Suite 150B, Commack, New York, 11725

Google Maps
Updated: 13 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 80/100
About

Dr. Sileo is widely praised for his surgical skill and down-to-earth personality. Most patients report successful recoveries and appreciate his willingness to explain options. However, there is a very vocal minority reporting failed surgeries and poor follow-up, which creates a polarized reputation.

Review Summary
20
Most Relevant
17
Newest
0
Highest
17
Lowest
Total Reviews Analyzed: 54
Performance Scores
Medical Expertise 75/100
Admin Efficiency 60/100
Pro Tip

Always ask for a detailed post-op plan and ensure you have a direct contact for follow-up concerns.

Specializes in sports injuries
Modern office facilities
Pros & Cons
What Works Well
  • Skilled surgeon
  • Friendly bedside manner
  • Thorough explanations
Areas to Improve
  • Reports of failed surgeries
  • Inconsistent follow-up
  • Staff availability
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Is he conservative with surgery?
  • How is the recovery process?
User Feedback

He rebuilt my shoulder and I'm pain-free.

I felt abandoned after my surgery failed.

Great doctor, very down to earth.

Location Details
Street
500 Commack Rd, Suite 150B
Neighborhood
Commack
City
State
Postcode
11725
Country
Coordinates
40.8227, -73.2916
Location
500 Commack Rd Suite 150B, Commack, NY 11725
Quick Info
Advertisement
📢
Your Ad Here
Reach thousands of
readers daily.
Related Businesses