586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, New York, 11953
Middle Island Pizza is a real mixed bag. Some long-time customers love it and swear by the food, while others have had terrible experiences with service and quality. It seems like a place that has its ups and downs, and your experience might depend on who's working that day. It's definitely not the most consistent spot in town.
We analyze 75 public reviews for Middle Island Pizza using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Try the Sicilian pizza if you like a thicker crust.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
Hit or miss.
Staff can be rude.
Used to be better.