Old Drovers Inn
196 E Duncan Hill Rd, Dover Plains, New York, 12522
Old Drovers Inn is a historic, charming destination that offers a unique, step-back-in-time experience. Guests consistently praise the warm hospitality, cozy rooms, and the historic ambiance. The restaurant is also highly regarded for its classic pub fare, particularly the cheddar cheese soup. While some diners have noted occasional inconsistencies in food quality or pricing, the overall experience is widely considered memorable and top-notch.
We analyze 69 public reviews for Old Drovers Inn using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
The cheddar cheese soup is legendary—make sure to order it during your visit.
✓ What Works Well
- Historic, charming atmosphere
- Warm and attentive hospitality
- Excellent cheddar cheese soup
✗ Areas to Improve
- Occasional food inconsistencies
- Pricing can be high
- Uneven floors (part of the charm)
- Is it family-friendly?
- Do they take reservations?
- Is the food authentic?
A memorable experience.
Great hospitality.
Historic and cozy.
- Category Hospitality
- City Dover Plains
- State New York
- Postcode 12522
- Country United States
readers daily.