Food & Beverage · NY Style Pizza
Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry FL
1455 FL-436, Suite 105, Casselberry, Florida, 32707
Google Maps
Updated: 18 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 65/100
About
This place is a polarizing spot. Long-time fans remember it as a local gem, but recent reviews suggest a decline in quality and service under new ownership. While some still enjoy the food, many complain about soggy pizza, poor service, and inconsistent quality. It's a spot that seems to be struggling to maintain its former reputation.
Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
14
Newest
20
Highest rating
20
Lowest rating
We analyze 74 public reviews for Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry FL using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Performance Scores
Food Taste
50/100
Value for Money
55/100
Pro Tip
Check your order before leaving, as order errors are common.
Wood-fired style
Large menu
Pros & Cons
✓ What Works Well
- Good garlic knots
- Friendly staff (sometimes)
- Large portions
✗ Areas to Improve
- Inconsistent quality
- Poor service
- Soggy pizza
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is it still good?
- Why is the service so bad?
- Is it authentic NY style?
User Feedback
Used to be the best.
Food is hit or miss.
Service is very inconsistent.
Quick Info
- Category Food & Beverage
- Neighborhood Casselberry
- City Casselberry
- State Florida
- Postcode 32707
- Country United States
More Food & Beverage
