351 W Main St, New Holland, Pennsylvania, 17557
Palermo Pizza is a polarizing spot in New Holland. Many locals swear by their massive portions and authentic Italian feel, while others have had frustrating experiences with service and order accuracy. When they are on their game, the food is spot on and a great value. However, the kitchen can be chaotic, and customer service seems to be a major pain point for some.
We analyze 69 public reviews for Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
The garlic knots and house dressing are local favorites.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
Best Italian food in the area when they get it right.
Portions are large enough to share.
Service can be a bit rough around the edges.