333 Cold Storage Rd, #202, Craig, Alaska, 99921
Papa's Pizza is a local favorite for its massive, tasty pies and shakes, but the service is a total rollercoaster. While many folks rave about the food quality, the wait times are often brutal and the front-of-house staff can be hit-or-miss. It is a go-to spot for islanders, but you might want to pack some patience. The atmosphere is cozy, though some diners complain about the heat inside. Overall, it is a solid spot if you are not in a rush.
We analyze 68 public reviews for Papa's Pizza using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Order the Papa Size if you want a real bang for the buck, but call ahead early to avoid the dinner rush.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
Food is spot on but service needs work.
Best pizza on the island, just be ready to wait.
New management seems to be struggling with staffing.