21 Robert Lucas Rd, Lucasville, Ohio, 45648
Sarah’s is widely loved for its cookies and coffee, with many locals calling it a gem. The atmosphere is warm and the staff are generally super friendly. While the baked goods are a huge hit, the hot food menu gets mixed reviews—some love the breakfast bowls, while others find them lacking in flavor. It is a great spot for a morning treat, but maybe stick to the sweets if you are picky about your savory meals.
We analyze 66 public reviews for Sarah’s Café and Bakery using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Order the cookies ahead of time if you need a large batch for an event.
✓ What Works Well
✗ Areas to Improve
The pumpkin cookies are a must-have.
Coffee is spot on.
Skip the breakfast burrito if you want big flavor.