Food & Beverage · Pizza & Italian
Sicilian Delight
40 Catherwood Rd, Ithaca, New York, 14850
Google Maps
Updated: 18 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 90/100
About
Sicilian Delight is a beloved local spot for authentic NY-style pizza. Many customers rave about the quality, friendly service, and the owner's personal touch. While there are some reports of inconsistent service and occasional quality issues, the overall consensus is that it's a top-tier choice for pizza in Ithaca.
Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
16
Newest
20
Highest rating
20
Lowest rating
We analyze 76 public reviews for Sicilian Delight using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
Performance Scores
Food Taste
95/100
Value for Money
85/100
Pro Tip
The owner is very hands-on; don't hesitate to ask for recommendations.
NY-style pizza
Mall location
Pros & Cons
✓ What Works Well
- Authentic NY-style pizza
- Friendly owner
- Great quality
✗ Areas to Improve
- Mall location
- Inconsistent service
- Occasional quality issues
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is it really NY-style?
- What's the best pizza to order?
- Is it worth the wait?
User Feedback
Best pizza in Ithaca
Authentic and delicious
Friendly staff
Quick Info
- Category Food & Beverage
- Neighborhood Ithaca
- City Ithaca
- State New York
- Postcode 14850
- Country United States
More Food & Beverage
