Gotham's Deli
224 E Market St, Smithfield, North Carolina, 27577
Gotham's Deli brings a slice of New York to Smithfield with its sports-themed decor and hearty sub sandwiches. Many regulars swear by the quality and flavor, often calling it the best deli in the area. However, some visitors from the North feel it doesn't quite hit the mark for authenticity, particularly regarding bagels and bread. Service is generally friendly, though some report long wait times and occasional order errors.
We analyze 71 public reviews for Gotham's Deli using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.
If you're a fan of pickles, be aware they are an extra charge, so factor that into your budget.
✓ What Works Well
- Generous portion sizes
- Fun New York sports theme
- Freshly prepared sandwiches
✗ Areas to Improve
- Some find the bread quality inconsistent
- Long wait times during busy periods
- Charging for pickles is a point of contention
- Do they have gluten-free bread?
- Is the food authentic NY style?
- Why do they charge for pickles?
The Reuben is the best I've ever had.
Great atmosphere, but the bread was soggy.
Friendly staff, but the wait can be long.
- Category Food & Beverage
- Neighborhood Downtown Smithfield
- City Smithfield
- State North Carolina
- Postcode 27577
- Country United States
