Food & Beverage in Middle Island, New York
10+ Businesses
Bagels 101
Bagels 101 is a polarizing spot in Middle Island. While some locals swear by their authentic NY-style bagels and breakf…
Middle Island Pizza
Middle Island Pizza is a real mixed bag. Some long-time customers love it and swear by the food, while others have had …
Taqueria Little Mexico
Taqueria Little Mexico is a popular spot for authentic Mexican food, with many customers praising the tacos and tortas.…
AYCE Mongolian Grill
AYCE Mongolian Grill offers a fun, interactive dining experience where you pick your own ingredients to be stir-fried. …
Athens Diner
Athens Diner is a classic, family-friendly spot that many locals consider a hidden gem. The menu is extensive, featurin…
Lucia Middle Island
Lucia in Middle Island is a beloved local gem, often praised for its fresh, delicious food and cozy, diner-like atmosph…
Good Wok Restaurant
Good Wok is a polarizing restaurant. Some customers love the fresh, flavorful food and friendly service, while others h…
Shah’s Halal Food
Shah's Halal is a go-to spot for many looking for quick, affordable, and tasty halal food. The portions are generally l…
MELTology Bar & Grilled Cheese
This spot is polarizing. Fans love the creative grilled cheese combinations, boozy shakes, and fun atmosphere. However,…
Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Capio's is highly regarded as the best pizza spot in the area by many locals. Customers love the fresh ingredients, fri…
readers daily.